Saturday, September 19, 2015

article on Intellectual Disabilities Review

The article "Evaluating the Effectiveness of an Intervention Program to Influence Attitudes of Students Towards Peers with Disabilities" reports the results of intervention program provided to kindergarteners and elementary students.  This study was created because how much the idea of inclusive education has been encouraged in the past decade. It says, "In this study[they]explored the possibilities of promoting more positive attitudes of kindergarten and elementary school students towards children with physical, intellectual and severe physical and intellectual disabilities through an intervention based on acquired knowledge" (de Boer, Sip, Minneaert, & Post, 2014). The study focused on what are attitudes like for students with no disabilities towards students with a mental and/or physical disability. It was a 3 weeks education project comprising six lessons about disabilities.  The students in the study were 4-12 years olds.  Students were surveyed about their attitudes before the intervention program, after the intervention program and a year later.  The study focused on three types of disabilities: autism, ADHD, and intellectual disability.

The article mentions the benefits of having an inclusive classroom.  Students without disabilities benefit from this experience academically and socially.  They show much greater progress in reading and mathematics.  Socially, they are more aware and understand people that may have a disability.  Socially students with a disability in an inclusive classroom setting improve their communication and interaction skills.  Still, the problem remained that students with disabilities had a hard time being accepted by their classmates.  And this where this study came about.  If students were prepared and became more knowledgeable about disabilities would their attitudes change?

The results were as follows:  students were found to have the least positive attitudes towards students with ADHD.  Students with autism and other disabilities received more positive attitudes from their classmates with no disabilities.  It was also found that girls have better attitudes towards classmates with disabilities than boys. Also, the study reports that there is a least positive attitude towards an intellectual disability than to a physical disability.  At the bottom of the article, you can find a sample of vignettes read to the students to introduce the discussion about a certain disability.

Although, there were some attitude changed at the end of the study, some questions remained.  One question, asking if this attitude change has been long term or forgotten as time passed.  I liked the study, because it sets up a predictor for future attitudes of students with no disabilities.  It gives an idea how a teacher or an entire school can be better prepare themselves and provide information to their students and provide a better academic and social experience for students with the disabilities.  They deserve the chance for everyone around them to be informed about their disability and this way, I think, can see past that and get to know who they are, even beyond that disability.

I also liked the study because it was very well planned out.  I like that it had a before and after survey and that it followed students after one year. Wouldn't it be cool to have educational programs come out to schools and provide knowledge to students regardless if they are inclusive or not.  I remember one of my first teaching years there was this girl, Amy, who had some sort of facial deformation and intellectual disability.  She was in a self-contained class but she was still had contact with her peers in the building, in the hallway, in the unified arts classes, in gym, and lunch.  It broke my heart one afternoon a group of 6th graders running down the hallway and hearing one of them say, "run, here comes the monster".  I didn't know who they were talking about until I saw Amy turn the corner saying, "wait, wait for me."  I brought it up to my team and I'm not sure what was done about the situation I don't remember.  But what I do remember is talking to my students that year and telling them, I can't control what the others in this school do or react to her, but I expect at least my students, not to be rude and respect her, be kind to her.  Various occasions I witness them doing that and felt proud of them.  But yeah, I still think school as a whole should prepare, inform students with no disabilities and TEACHERS it takes a village after all, right?

de Boer, A., Sip Pijl, S.J.,  Minnaert, A., & Post W. (2014, March 1) Evaluating the effectiveness of an intervention program to influence attitudes of students towards peers with disabilities. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, volume 44 (3), 572-583.
http://ezproxy.trnty.edu:3062/ehost/detail/detail?sid=85cef7c2-50dd-4a86-9b0f-5a18180c8dc2%40sessionmgr4005&vid=19&hid=4109&bdata=#AN=EJ1038290&db=eric

6 comments:

  1. I am having trouble indenting after my first line on my cited information. I've pressed enter and the tab key but it doesn't seem to work, if you know of a better or different way please let me know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you type in WORD you can click paragraph then "hanging"

      Delete
  2. Gabby- I enjoyed reading your article and your comments. I will say that the "meanness" of students, especially middle schoolers, is very disturbing. My current school does an anti-bullying program every September. Unfortunately, I haven't seen much difference. The best results I have seen is when a teacher or another adult steps in. I also agree that intellectual disabilities, if not severe, are the easiest to hide. Many students don't even realize their is any difference between themselves and their peers ( a very good thing:) In fact, when I taught 8th grade inclusion the past few years, general education students would be so jealous that they didn't get to meet with the high school to pick their classes and get their schedules during the spring months. Little did they know that their peers had a transition meeting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a great article! I think it is so important to teach children that everyone is different and if we were all the same, that would be boring. Teaching children to care about others, stand up for those who can't stand up for themselves, is always a great idea. However, I think it needs to go beyond the anti-bullying campaign that usually takes place in October. As much as we want others to be included and feel like a part of the "regular ed" kids, it's also important for us to make them feel like it's ok to be who they are, different. Different is just as important.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Such a good point! "Different is just as important" I struggle with this with my own daughters: My oldest is crazy smart and she attends an ivy league college. My second daughter is also smart but I feel like she always apologizes for "not being as smart as her sister". She is an amazing softball player too. She balances school, work and sports. They are BOTH amazing!

      Delete
  4. I found this article to be so intriguing! I find it very interesting that students in the study seem to have the least acceptance for students with ADHD. I wonder why this is....is it because they are impulsive and demand a lot of the teacher's/classes attention? That gives us some perspective on how we work with students with ADHD and how we prepare them socially. So many great topics in this article...awesome find!

    ReplyDelete